Office of the Saskatchewan Information and Privacy Commissioner. Guide to LA FOIP, Chapter 5, Third Party Information. Updated 22 February 2023. 57 Clearly outweigh: If a public interest is established, it must then be balanced against the purpose of the exemption that has been found to apply to determine whether it clearly outweighs that purpose. The public interest override provision recognizes that while exemptions serve to protect valid interests, they must occasionally yield to an overriding public interest to access the information that has been requested.148 An important consideration when determining whether the public interest in releasing the information clearly outweighs the purpose of the exemption is the extent to which denying access to the information in the circumstances would be consistent with the very purpose of the exemption.149 Some things to consider regarding any invasion of privacy: • Consider the representations made by the affected individuals arguing against disclosure. • Should the affected individuals’ privacy rights be given preference over the public interest that exists in disclosing the record. The federal Privacy Act has a substantially similar provision. Subsection 8(2)(m)(i) of the Privacy Act also considers whether “the public interest in disclosure clearly outweighs any invasion of privacy”. The federal Privacy Commissioner established an invasion of privacy test. Local authorities can apply this test to determine the level of privacy risk in the disclosure.150 The test involves three interrelated risk factors that will help local authorities determine whether the public interest in disclosure clearly outweighs any invasion of privacy: a. Sensitivity of the information • Consider whether the type of information is of a detailed (e.g., name and address) or highly personal (e.g., health information) nature. • Evaluate the context in which the information was collected and determine whether any contextual sensitivities apply to the information. For example, a list of public servants may not be considered particularly sensitive, but that same list, if collected to identify employees having a specific illness would be considered sensitive based on the context. 148 ON IPC resource, Public Interest Disclosure, September 2021, at p. 6. 149 ON IPC resource, Public Interest Disclosure, September 2021, at p. 7. 150 Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, Public interest disclosures by federal institutions under the Privacy Act, June 2022, available http://Public interest disclosures by federal institutions under the Privacy Act - Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada. Accessed Sept. 1, 2022.
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MTgwMjYzOA==